.png)
Recruiting new life insurance agents is easy. Building successful ones is not.
Every manager in our business knows this: enthusiasm fills the room during recruitment, but only a handful of new agents survive their first year.
The difference between those who last and those who quit often lies not in their background, but in the kind of manager they have.
If you want to build a strong and lasting team, you must understand the three biggest challenges every rookie faces — and how you, as their leader, can help them overcome each one.
Fear of Rejection and Self-Doubt
The Problem:
Many new agents join full of energy, only to lose confidence after a few “no’s.”
Rejection hits hard, especially for those who’ve never sold before. Some take it personally and withdraw before they even gain momentum.
Your Role as Manager:
- Teach them to expect rejection from day one.
- Create an environment where effort is celebrated, not just results.
- Track activity, not just production. A rookie who makes 10 calls and hears 10 “no’s” should be congratulated for effort, because confidence grows through repetition.
Leadership Example:
The great Ben Feldman started no differently. Rejected countless times early in his career, he refined his message until clients saw the value beyond the policy. He famously said,
“Don’t sell life insurance. Sell what life insurance can do.”
As a manager, your task is to help rookies see rejection not as failure, but as feedback, and to coach them toward better conversations, not fewer calls.
Inconsistent Prospecting Habits
The Problem:
Rookies often burn through their warm market, friends and relatives within the first month. When that list runs out, panic begins. Without structure, their calendar goes empty.
Your Role as Manager:
- Instill discipline early.
- Require daily prospecting time, I call it the Power Hour: one solid hour every day dedicated only to reaching new people. Monitor it, model it, and make it part of your team culture.
- Encourage rookies to ask for referrals even from non-buyers. Teach them to view every conversation as an opportunity to expand their reach.
Leadership Example:
Joe Gandolfo, one of the all-time greats, sold over $71 million in life insurance in a single year. His formula? Meet five new prospects daily, without fail.
Managers who can help rookies build that same rhythm are the ones who produce consistent performers, not lucky closers.
Overemphasis on Product Knowledge, Lack of Emotional Connection
The Problem:
Rookies often memorize features and benefits but miss the emotional core of the sale.
They talk about “sum assured” and “premium schedules,” but not about security, legacy, or love.
Your Role as Manager:
- Shift their focus from selling products to serving people.
- Make “story-selling” part of your training.
- Have them share why they joined the business, their personal “why.” When they learn to connect emotionally, the presentation becomes a conversation, not a lecture.
Leadership Example:
Mary Kay Ash, who built one of the largest direct-selling empires, taught her team to lead with empathy. She said,
“Pretend every person has a sign around their neck that says, ‘Make me feel important.’”
When you train rookies with that mindset, they stop pitching and start connecting, and that’s when true selling begins.
Leading Beyond Numbers
Your role as a manager isn’t just to recruit, it’s to build people who can sell with heart and stay with purpose.
Anyone can recruit agents. But great managers develop professionals.
When you help rookies conquer fear, build consistency, and sell with empathy, you’re not just building a team, you’re building a legacy.
After all, every legend in this business began as a rookie.
The question is: will you be the manager who helps create the next one?
All the best my friends!!
#acgadvice
